For the Wynn

I write about o11y, tech, philosophy, and more.

What Makes A Good Star Wars Movie


As The Last Jedi starts to hit theaters, it seems appropriate for me to write down what makes a good Star Wars movie. My take is a simpler metric than others might consider, completley disregarding plot and character development. It goes like this:

A graph, displaying how lightsabers correlate to joy in Star Wars, namely up and to the right

It’s that easy. Play Duel of the Fates, turn on a lightsaber (preferably two), and I AM IN.

It’s worth calling out that by this metric, I judge the prequals as wholly enjoyable movies (for the sum total of the time lightsabers are active). Character development? Plot? Onscreen chemistry? Don’t care, don’t care, don’t care. All I saw was Darth Maul lighting up the second lightsaber, Obi Wan avenging his mentor, Yoda kicking butt, and the Emperor pulling out the red goods. Seriously, I must’ve watched the fight scenes with Darth Maul at least a hundred times.

This is why Episode Seven and Rogue One really missed the mark. No lightsabers. Rogue One has a host of other issues, but this is by far the most important one.

I have hope that the new film will set us back on a more lightsaber-ful path… but we’ll have to see.